Andrew Pollack's Blog

Technology, Family, Entertainment, Politics, and Random Noise

Government is not formed from the top down.

By Andrew Pollack on 09/15/2007 at 10:30 AM EDT

Nation Building is a 20th Century idea and it’s time to move on. I’m speaking of course about what we’re trying to do in Iraq, but the discussion is much larger than that. The whole of the 20th century with all its fantastic advances in health, wealth, and happiness for the world’s wealthier nations has been a disaster defined by nothing so much as the – sometimes unintended -- consequences of our misguided attempts to bring our brand of success and values to the less successful and less powerful. The more I think about how this comes to be, the more I am sure that our mistake is thinking we can layer the entire structure of our system onto someone else’s society without paying any attention to how we ourselves got here. The most successful Governments did not spring into being as large centrally controlled structures with the confidence and trust of the governed. They came about as a gradual merger of power from the local community level, to the regional, and finally to a national representational level. Government is not formed from the top down.

As an American, I have of course studied our own history more than that of any other nation so I’ll use it here as the example. We are the United States because before that we were just individual “States”. Unification was not instant and was not all encompassing. The first attempts were successful only in so far as they led to the later ones. The “Articles of Confederation” were a loose affiliation by comparison with the Constitution which followed. Much of our history can be viewed as a slow but inexorable movement from local control toward central authority.

A clue as to the innate nature of a society’s resistance to larger, more distant control is found if you look at which aspects of life remain largely the provinces of local decisions in comparison to those which have been more readily seceded to the federal level. The schools, for example, remain closely held and controlled. Laws governing ‘moral’ decisions have also been kept as local as possible. Economic laws and the military have much more readily been centralized. We don’t care who prints the money we use, but if someone steals it we want local law enforcement to punish them. It is a matter of trust, and it stems from the most basic of human social units. Trust stems from the family.

We start learning trust at the family, and as we get older we learn to extend our definition of family to our neighbors. We trust our neighbors to make decisions like ours. As towns then, we made decisions but outside forces bring the need to expand still more. We band our town-families together and form regional governments. Regions form nation-states, and ultimately states form unions. The United States is literally a union of such nation-states.

The problem with so called “Nation Building” comes when it is imposed backward. In Iraq we are attempting to build a “coalition government” at the top by using representatives from the community but we have been too much ignoring the time consuming process of first rebuilding strong, viable, local governmental bodies. A national government is no good if it must impose its will using national forces. The latest reports are proving this out. Local villages report that they trust their local forces, but the national police force is terrifying to them. Are we so different? Do we not have a whole mythology in this country evident in our books and films of the “Federal” system being corrupt while our local police force must hold the line and do what is right?

We would do well in Iraq and elsewhere to focus less on the big national picture and more on supporting the growth of healthy units of local government gaining the confidence of their own people, and slowly growing together to shift only those issues of national significance up the chain to regional representation and ultimately to a national body. We must focus on helping to build a government from the bottom up.

There are  - loading -  comments....

re: Government is not formed from the top down.By Chris Whisonant on 09/15/2007 at 11:25 AM EDT
Have you not seen what's going on in Iraq? Of course there's a focus on the
national government, but we're also trying to stabilize more local regions as
well. Have you heard of what we're doing in Anbar? Getting the locals to assist
in turning over people and changing their minds. Kind of the whole tenor of
your last paragraph. Check out this and some of the other stories of Anbar:

Perhaps we should have done more with the national governments of Germany after
Your point is a good one - I'm surprised frankly, that we haven't seen it evoked more by the right wing side of the argumentBy Andrew Pollack on 09/15/2007 at 02:54 PM EDT
WWII is in large part a direct outgrowth of an unfinished WWI -- halted as it
was more by the utter exhaustion of its participants and the 1918 flu
epidemic. So much unfinished business and an incomplete reconstruction of a
once proud nation made the rise of a new tyrant almost predictable.

That said, I haven't heard the side pushing for continued effort in Iraq using
that argument much at all. At least not directly.

As for your comment about our work in the provinces of Iraq, it is happening
but its incomplete and totally unrelated to the work of pushing a central
governmental body. They'll prop up anyone who happens to side with them at a
local level, but the real money and direct effort is still being leveraged from
the top down.
re: Your point is a good one - I'm surprised frankly, that we haven't seen it evoked more by the right wing side of the argumentBy Chris Whisonant on 09/16/2007 at 08:18 PM EDT
There are a lot of good arguments that should probably be used...

Anyway, you know what really scares me - 2009. If you think about it, the last
two terrorist attacks on our soil were in 1993 and 2001 just after
administration changes. :(

Other Recent Stories...

  1. 10/08/2018Will you be at the NYC Launch Event for HCL Domino v10 -- Find me!Come find me in NYC on Wednesday at the Launch Event if you're there. I really do want to talk to ...... 
  2. 09/04/2018With two big projects on hold, I suddenly find myself very available for new short and long term projects. In twenty five years, I don't think I've ever written an entry like this, but if you need the kind of work I do now would be a great time to get in touch. Both of the big projects I had lined up for late summer and early fall have been placed on hold and will be that way for a while. With the kids now all off at college and careers, I'm open to more travel than such than I have been in decades, but unless something else comes along, I'll be here working on updates to Second Signal and other things that ...... 
  3. 07/13/2018Who is HCL and why is it a good thing that they are now the ones behind Notes and Domino?We need to address some biases here. IBM has made a deal under which the Notes & Domino software and intellectual property is now being developed and maintained by HCL America. HCL America is part of the very large "HCL Technologies" company that has grown from its roots in India to become an 8 Billion Dollar company with a global presence in the IT Industry. You could be excused for initially believing, as many people do when they hear this, that "they've outsourced the code to India where they'll milk it ...... 
  4. 03/21/2018Domino Apps on IOS is a Game Changer. Quit holding back. 
  5. 02/15/2018Andrew’s Proposed Gun Laws 
  6. 05/05/2016Is the growing social-sourced economy the modern back door into socialism? 
  7. 04/20/2016Want to be whitelisted? Here are some sensible rules for web site advertising 
  8. 12/30/2015Fantastic new series on Syfy called “The Expanse” – for people who love traditional science fiction 
  9. 10/20/2015My suggestion is to stay away from PayAnywhere(dot)com  
  10. 08/07/2015Here is one for you VMWARE gurus - particularly if you run ESXi without fancy drive arrays 
Click here for more articles.....

pen icon Comment Entry
Your Name
*Your Email
* Your email address is required, but not displayed.
Your thoughts....
Remember Me  

Please wait while your document is saved.