Andrew Pollack's Blog

Technology, Family, Entertainment, Politics, and Random Noise

Followup - more test data with really interesting results

By Andrew Pollack on 02/23/2004 at 01:35 PM EST

I modified the test (described here: http://www.thenorth.com/apblog2.nsf/0/816E292DD0A455E385256E3F0079C823 ) to try to make it resist things like random server performance changes due to whatever else the machine is doing. I've also tried to eliminate a few other variables.

The four tests were performed all at once. Each was performed 10 times, but not in order. A loop to 40 was created, and a modulus function was used to determine which test ran (e.g. if counter equaled 23, then 23/4 = 5 r3, so test 3 was run). The times listed are cumulative from all tens runs of each test. That should have mixed it up enough.

I've put the results in order. You'll notice that pipelined communication to the Domino server is clearly indicated over multiple concurrent communication. Within that, however, is the interesting result that even pipelined there is about a small advantage to having multiple Domino sessions. Personally, I think this is a terribly small advantage and in a servlet environment where the concurrency will not be quite so exact the contention should be lessened enough to make this negligible.

My own conclusion from this, is that based on the compromises of code simplicity, performance, and stability a single pipelined I/O queue thread as a static class should be the best way to handle all the Domino I/O for a single server. At some point I'll test multiple server access through the DIIOP thread.

The three machines are all running the same jvm (1.4) though the code is compiled as 1.3 compatible classes.

The single processor machine is my workstation, a cheap 1.7ghz Celeron with 1gb of RAM.

The "faster" of the two duals is a Dual P4 700mhz with 1gb of RAM, but its running a bunch of other stuff too. Also, that was the same machine as the Domino server, which tosses in some weird possibilities for contention but matches the real world case of where many java agents and servlets run.

The slower of the two duals is a Dual P-II 350mhz with 512megs of RAM running Windows NT (Yeah, yeah, but its still nice machine).


Single Processor Machine:

Test 2: 34,220ms. Pipelined, two sessions.
Test 1: 42,423ms. Pipelined, one session.
Test 4: 47,722ms. Threaded, two sessions.
Test 3: 53,765ms. Threaded, one session.

Dual Processor Machine, same machine as Domino:

Test 2: 37,596ms. Pipelined, two sessions.
Test 1: 40,155ms. Pipelined, one session.
Test 4: 51,767ms. Threaded, two sessions.
Test 3: 53,032ms. Threaded, one session.

Slower dual processor machine:

Test 2: 43,327ms. Pipelined, two sessions.
Test 1: 45,576ms. Pipelined, one session.
Test 3: 57,874ms. Threaded, one session.
Test 4: 67,298ms. Threaded, two sessions.


  • car icon

    On Site Training

    We can bring the same kind of top quality training you get at conferences right to your offices. If your team needs training in a single topic, or you want to do a whole series on site, we can put a mini-conference together just for your team. For more information, Contact Me.
  • There are  - loading -  comments....



    Other Recent Stories...

    1. 02/09/2014Changing what I do at the Fire DepartmentSo, here’s a bit of a change. A couple of weeks ago I let the chief know that it was time for me to step down as the Lieutenant of our Engine 1. Once a replacement is chosen, I’ll still be a firefighter but won’t be an officer any longer. There are a number of reasons for this, but the best explanation I can give is that it is time to let someone else grow into that role and make their own contribution, while at the same time I’ve got plenty of other things going on that keep me from putting as much time ...... 
    2. 02/07/2014Dammit. I think I broke facebook. ...... 
    3. 02/06/2014Sochi Olympics Pub Chat - Now OpenAs in years past, I've created a group Skype chat room for anyone who wants to use it while watching the Olympics. We've had fun with this in the past, as long as nobody takes it too seriously. Here's a link: skype:?chat&blob=1-XgYKMLG_kK5fqEsq4t4Jd4GLxHZxbMIqSYtCRXS9DiF5WNjBtuljOtcSDqaGdkOv5mX6paJQSuNuI ** Don't expect much traffic in there until Friday's opening event ** A few recommendations: 1. Definitely use the skype command '/alertsoff' so when you're not watching you won't get bugged by the rest of ...... 
    4. 02/05/2014Question for mobile app developers - what development platform do you recommend? 
    5. 02/03/2014Are you using a Surface Pro 2 or another Windows 8.1 Tablet? Want to use Traveler on the touch screen? It works! 
    6. 02/03/2014Some thoughts from IBM Connect 2014 
    7. 01/28/2014Understanding the decision behind Connections Mail 
    8. 01/19/2014Snap Review - Microsoft Surface Pro 2 - Tablet, Laptop Replacement, or Both 
    9. 10/31/2013You Need to Wish Gab Davis a Happy Birthday Today 
    10. 10/14/2013To connect or not to connect 
    Click here for more articles.....


    pen icon Comment Entry
    Subject
    Your Name
    Homepage
    *Your Email
    * Your email address is required, but not displayed.
     
    Your thoughts....
     
    Remember Me  

    Please wait while your document is saved.