Andrew Pollack's Blog

Technology, Family, Entertainment, Politics, and Random Noise

The mis-use of Twitter as a chat room - and what to do about it

By Andrew Pollack on 08/12/2008 at 04:23 PM EDT

Twitter has ripped through our community like a wave, capturing the time wasting cycles and a few more than that from quite a few people. The problem is, its totally the wrong tool for us. Twitter is meant to be a tool to tell your friends and followers "what you're doing" so they can meet up with you. It isn't meant as a chat room at all. Most messages should be one line saying "I'm here, doing this."

Twitter has become -- for many in the Domino Blogger community -- a kind of limited chat room. Why? Because there is a need for a social space like that. We want to be having side conversations while we're working, sitting through boring meetings, watching television, or whatever else. We enjoy that. We get to know each other better, and we keep in touch with those we know fairly well.

The truth is, Twitter is absolutely terrible if used as this tool. The latency is ridiculous, the stability is poor, and the functionality is extremely limited.

On top of that, using Twitter this way is swamping Twitter. The tool itself can't survive the use of it as a chat room on a large scale. The architecture is wrong for it.

So why do we use it?

We use it because its a free, wide open, many-to-many unplanned chatter tool with a very low barrier to entry. There are other tools like that though, which are better suited to what we want.

So what should be done? That's fairly straightforward. We should establish a Domino Bloggers community chat channel on IRC, or public chat room on Skype, or something similar.

There are tools designed for community chats. The most long standing of these is IRC (Internet Relay Chat). Other tools like the Skype public chat I'm using for the Olympic Side Chat work too. I picked the Skype one because most of our community is comfortable with Skype and wouldn't need to figure out IRC. Skype also gives you consistent credentials, where IRC really doesn't. If you log out, someone can log in and take your name. There are other tools out there, including some great tools for Linux but overall, so far Skype seems to be the most ubiquitous.

The latest versions of Skype offer something very similar. You can create a public chat room and even advertise it if you want. You don't have to establish credentials with the others to join, either. You can easily just "jump in" and "jump out" when you want. It does have the idea of admins and access rights that can be open or closed, but open is fine for most of us.

What's your thought? How many people do you think would consider the idea of no longer using TWITTER as a chat room, but instead using it to say "I'm in the Domino Coffee Room" -- which is what Twitter was meant for? Is Skype a good choice?


  • car icon

    On Site Training

    We can bring the same kind of top quality training you get at conferences right to your offices. If your team needs training in a single topic, or you want to do a whole series on site, we can put a mini-conference together just for your team. For more information, Contact Me.
  • There are  - loading -  comments....

    re: The mis-use of Twitter as a chat room - and what to do about itBy Dave A. on08/12/2008 at 05:06 PM EDT
    Comment Loading
    Ok, but the fact that the tool is failing under the load?By Andrew Pollack on08/12/2008 at 05:10 PM EDT
    Comment Loading
    re: The mis-use of Twitter as a chat room - and what to do about itBy Chris Whisonant on08/12/2008 at 05:11 PM EDT
    Comment Loading
    I tried this Chris, for a couple of hours.By Andrew Pollack on08/12/2008 at 05:40 PM EDT
    Comment Loading
    re: I tried this Chris, for a couple of hours.By Chris Whisonant on08/12/2008 at 09:30 PM EDT
    Comment Loading
    re: The mis-use of Twitter as a chat room - and what to do about itBy Nathan T. Freeman on08/12/2008 at 05:19 PM EDT
    Comment Loading
    re: The mis-use of Twitter as a chat room - and what to do about itBy Justin on08/12/2008 at 05:30 PM EDT
    Comment Loading
    re: The mis-use of Twitter as a chat room - and what to do about itBy Justin on08/12/2008 at 05:35 PM EDT
    Comment Loading
    re: The mis-use of Twitter as a chat room - and what to do about itBy Yancy Lent on08/12/2008 at 10:36 PM EDT
    Comment Loading
    re: The mis-use of Twitter as a chat room - and what to do about itBy Chris Blatnick on08/12/2008 at 11:24 PM EDT
    Comment Loading
    re: The mis-use of Twitter as a chat room - and what to do about itBy Alan Lepofsky on08/13/2008 at 10:01 AM EDT
    Comment Loading
    re: The mis-use of Twitter as a chat room - and what to do about itBy Ben Rose on08/13/2008 at 12:40 PM EDT
    Comment Loading


    Other Recent Stories...

    1. 02/14/2010Great weekend sleddingI'm from "away" -- a term which in Maine speak means that I wasn't born here, and while I've been here for nearly 20 years I am very easily spotted as a non-native to pretty much anyone with long time family roots in the area. Being from away, there are things I just hadn't had a chance to do that most Mainer's take for granted. This weekend, I got the chance to scratch a few of those off the list. These included going 'upta camp', being significantly north of Bangor, and spending a fair bit of time on a ...... 
    2. 02/10/2010Is anyone really considering a move to a hosted Exchange system?I got this press release today from someone I really should learn to just ignore -- but I couldn't help myself. I actually read it. What struck me as the most odd set of statements in it focused on the idea that small and medium businesses are migrating away from Notes and into hosted exchange environments. In other words, that the move for small business into the cloud was somehow based on ISV's hosting off-site Microsoft Exchange mail servers for people. I suppose there must be some out there. This one ...... 
    3. 02/06/2010When does an application stop belonging to its owner?When an application becomes truly successful and people start relying on it for things they consider important, is there a point at which the application starts to belong to the owners? Facebook's latest change brings the topic to mind, but it can happen to you with internal applications as well. There comes a time when users begin to have a personal stake in the design of a good application. Facebook makes a great example for when your users really own your application. Its user base is both extremely ...... 
    4. 01/29/2010Lotusphere 2010 - Session Survey Results 
    5. 01/27/2010Is UPS just plain broken? * Updated 
    6. 01/25/2010My presentations posted here from Lotusphere 2010 
    7. 01/24/2010Me - in bobblehead form 
    8. 01/23/2010Announcing the C.U.L.T. Shirt 2010 Winner 
    9. 01/19/2010Great round table with Kristen Lauria about the Lotus Knows campaign 
    10. 01/19/2010The Review: Lotusphere 2010 – Opening General Session 
    Click here for more articles.....


    pen icon Comment Entry
    Subject
    Your Name
    Homepage
    *Your Email
    * Your email address is required, but not displayed.
     
    Your thoughts....
     
    Remember Me  

    Please wait while your document is saved.