Andrew Pollack's Blog

Technology, Family, Entertainment, Politics, and Random Noise

Gaming Planet Lotus is juvinile and destructively arrogant

By Andrew Pollack on 06/21/2008 at 07:42 PM EDT

Someone pinged me on IM today and pointed out that it was very likely someone had used a hack similar to one I pointed out to Yancy a few months back that could allow someone to "game the system" as it were and rack up endless link count numbers on Planet Lotus. It's not a difficult hack to accomplish and fairly tricky to defend against (though not impossible).

I don't really know if the post in question is actually being manipulated that way. I'm told it has more link hit numbers than there are daily visitors to the site though. I also have no idea if the blog site owner is behind it. I somewhat doubt it.

At the very least, the numbers mean that someone posted a link to the blog story on a busy site using the Planet Lotus link rather than a direct link to the blog story. Even that much is clearly a manipulation of the system. There is a way to be much more manipulative than that. I know, I showed Yancy a proof of concept months ago. It doesn't require a rocket scientist to figure out either, so doing it doesn't prove you've got any kind of skill. If someone is going to the trouble of doing that kind of thing (which I'm not going to detail) they're a real loser.

Planet Lotus has been a great boon to the Domino blogging community. For readers, it has brought together a really great way to see across the breadth of the community in a glance. You see things you otherwise wouldn't have seen by just subscribing to one blog or another. For writers, it has added a little competitiveness to the game that can drive us to write more of the kinds of things other people want to read.

Some bloggers will claim it doesn't change what or how they write. It may even be true for some. I know it has had an influence on my writing. I try to keep it a positive influence and I still write only what I want to write, but it definitely makes me think a bit more about what others might find of value.

I have no idea really if what's going on today is anomalous or part of a purposeful attempt to game the system. It doesn't really matter. My message to anyone who thinks that gaming the system is funny or shows how clever you are is simple. It's a loser play. It isn't original, it is trackable with a bit of research, and ultimately your own reputation will suffer for it, and worst of all it ruins some aspects of an otherwise fantastic resource.


  • text bubble icon

    Security Review

    How secure is your Domino environment? A security review doesn't have to be expensive to be helpful. If you're interested in finding out more, Contact Me.
  • There are  - loading -  comments....

    re: Gaming Planet Lotus is juvinile and destructively arrogantBy Vitor Pereira on 06/22/2008 at 09:52 AM EDT
    Comment Loading
    re: Gaming Planet Lotus is juvinile and destructively arrogantBy John Head on 06/22/2008 at 12:13 PM EDT
    Comment Loading
    re: Gaming Planet Lotus is juvinile and destructively arrogantBy Vitor Pereira on 06/22/2008 at 01:42 PM EDT
    Comment Loading
    re: Gaming Planet Lotus is juvinile and destructively arrogantBy John Head on 06/22/2008 at 02:59 PM EDT
    Comment Loading
    re: Gaming Planet Lotus is juvinile and destructively arrogantBy Vitor Pereira on 06/22/2008 at 06:08 PM EDT
    Comment Loading
    Lets keep in mind, we do not know....By Andrew Pollack on 06/22/2008 at 05:01 PM EDT
    Comment Loading
    re: Gaming Planet Lotus is juvinile and destructively arrogantBy Greyhawk68 on 06/23/2008 at 11:38 AM EDT
    Comment Loading
    re: Gaming Planet Lotus is juvinile and destructively arrogantBy Ed Brill on 06/23/2008 at 12:46 PM EDT
    Comment Loading
    re: Gaming Planet Lotus is juvinile and destructively arrogantBy Greyhawk68 on 06/23/2008 at 01:02 PM EDT
    Comment Loading
    You're after something different.By Andrew Pollack on 06/23/2008 at 01:16 PM EDT
    Comment Loading
    re: You're after something different.By Greyhawk68 on 06/23/2008 at 02:06 PM EDT
    Comment Loading
    Well, as far as twitter, links in IM, etc...By Andrew Pollack on 06/23/2008 at 02:16 PM EDT
    Comment Loading
    re: Gaming Planet Lotus is juvinile and destructively arrogantBy Vitor Pereira on 06/23/2008 at 05:18 PM EDT
    Comment Loading
    re: Gaming Planet Lotus is juvinile and destructively arrogantBy Yancy Lent on 06/23/2008 at 06:01 PM EDT
    Comment Loading


    Other Recent Stories...

    1. 05/13/2013Successfully moved away from POSTINI to SPAMHERO - some thoughts...It's been almost a year since Google announced the changes in their "Postini" offering. I've been looking around, and finally chose to give [Spamhero] a try. As of today, I'm 100% switched over. Here's what I found, and a tip... Accuracy: I'm can definitely tell you is that Spamhero is accurate. I've had no false positives so far, and just a few spam messages that have gotten through. I had many more of both with Postini. For what spam does get through, you get a custom email address to forward the ...... 
    2. 03/22/2013BLUG A3 : Stuff Andrew Thinks You Should Know - The Presentation is now available for downloadThe BLUG conference was amazing. I had a great time, saw many people I really like, and watched a great deal of technical skill transfer take place as well as some wonderful peer to peer mentoring happening between some of the most experienced in our community and some of the newest members. Scott Souder gave a fantastic opening keynote talk that was fresh, frank, and encouraging. I love his energy and attitude, as well has his respect for the core products. Louis Richardson also did a great job. He makes ...... 
    3. 03/15/2013Looking at SAML and OAUTH in the Notes and Domino 9 Public BetaAm I reading this right? Seriously? Like many people, when I read that next release of the Domino Server and Client were going to support OAuth and SAML, I was pretty happy with that. I've been a bit late getting around to looking at the beta though -- after all, IBM has made it quite clear that my opinion isn't all that welcome any more -- and I'm just now reading the documentation on how IBM is going about this. I'll know more when I talk about this stuff next week at BLUG, by the way. First SAML. I know ...... 
    4. 02/11/2013Just made plane and hotel reservations for BNUG -- my first time at that event.  
    5. 02/03/2013Can Software be Too Social to Succeed? 
    6. 02/01/2013Thoughts about the Opening General Session at Connect 2013 -- Do you have any? 
    7. 01/27/2013Who is to blame for the failure of Domino as public web server? IBM (Lotus) Product Management 
    8. 01/21/2013Small progress taking the first real steps in moving Second Signal off IBM Domino 
    9. 01/08/2013Does the Executive Branch of the U.S. Government (the President) have the Constitutional Authority to _NOT_ spend money allocated by the Congress? 
    10. 12/29/2012Have made some progress in chosing a new platform. 
    Click here for more articles.....


    pen icon Comment Entry
    Subject
    Your Name
    Homepage
    *Your Email
    * Your email address is required, but not displayed.
     
    Your thoughts....
     
    Remember Me  

    Please wait while your document is saved.